Summary
Willow is a world renown super model on sabbatical, working at her family’s inn. It’s a temporary gig while a new manager makes the transition into the job, but it’s perfectly timed. Willow is feeling burned out from her fast paced life. She’s looking forward to quiet time with her sisters and time out of the spotlight.
Corbin was a stud on the football field – before his injury. But his career is over, so he’s going to kick off his retirement with a lot of physical therapy and some remodeling therapy by fixing up an old house with his dad. Corbin needs a project to occupy his time, and it will help him keep an eye on his dad who has cancer.
Four years ago, a series of choices led Willow and Corbin to break up. Willow is still heart broken when she thinks of the choices she made, and angry when she thinks of the choices Corbin made. She’d prefer to never see Corbin again. But Corbin’s niece, Charlotte, is a huge fan. And she is convinced that Willow is the person who can help her solve a 40-year-old family mystery. So when Charlotte asks Willow to help her, Willow can’t help but say yes. She has no idea, though, that Charlotte has made Corbin part of the team as well. This means Willow is now stuck in regular contact with the man who broke her heart.
Review
I struggled to figure out if this story wanted to be a romance or a mystery. While I think it was stronger on the romance side, I feel like the story suffered from a minor identity crisis. It tried to be both at once, and it wasn’t all I hoped for on either side. The mystery was interesting. I love cold case stories. It was odd to have a football player and a model trying to dig into it, though. The characters acknowledged that oddity, which helped. But they uncovered a lot of big things pretty easily. As a seasoned mystery reader, it felt all too simple. And the mystery pieces at times got in the way of the flow of the romance, interfering with my enjoyment of the story just on that level.
The sign of a great Christian fiction book for me is that reading it becomes a spiritual experience. If it connects me to God or it prompts me to examine my own spiritual life, I feel like the story works from a faith perspective. This book just did not click for me on that spiritual level. The spiritual pieces were okay – I just didn’t feel like the integration was as smooth as I have found in some other stories. This aspect of the story wasn’t “bad,” but wasn’t all it could have been for me as a reader.
I liked the characters. This is a second book in a series about Willow and her sisters. I haven’t read book one, but that didn’t impact my understanding of this story. I am intrigued by the story line for book one and might consider giving it a try. The chemistry between Willow and Corbin, and the situation with Corbin’s dad saved the story for me and kept me engaged to the end. I cared about how they were going to deal with their history, and I found the ending satisfying.
Thanks to the folks at Netgalley and Bethany House for the opportunity to read an electronic review copy of this book. All opinions are my own.