REVIEW: Everyone This Christmas Has a Secret by Benjamin Stevenson

Summary


Ernest Cunningham lays out the tropes and expectations of the “holiday special” mystery and then takes readers through his own “holiday special” which he compares to an Advent Calendar – “23 clues and a killer.”

Ernest’s ex wife has been arrested for the brutal murder of her romantic partner, a wealthy philanthropist. And she asks Ern to solve the mystery.

Ernest starts working through Lyle’s business associates from his foundation as well as the recovering addicts working at the theatre with magician Rylan Blaze. Before Ernest gets very far in his investigation, another body drops, and he has to determine who killed both of the victims – before Christmas.

Review


Wow, was this twisty! Once I started, I didn’t want to put it down. [One of the features of Ernest’s latest story is it can be read like an advent calendar, one chapter a day for each day of December until Christmas. But I know I wouldn’t have been able to stop at one chapter a day!]

Fans of earlier books in the series will be happy to know there are a few new rules this time around for the “holiday special.” I thought the insertions of Ern’s post-story reflections as he writes were less intrusive this time around – or maybe I’m just more accustomed to the unusual storytelling now that we are three books in. I’m still reeling over the big reveals at the end – this was SO cleverly put together. And it’s actually a holiday mystery with holiday elements – not just a full mystery that happens to take place in December.

Series fans should NOT miss this one! It’s so good. I think newcomers could start here as there aren’t many references to Ernest’s past or insider knowledge necessary. But I think Ern’s style – of storytelling and of mystery solving – makes more sense in the context of the series read in order. (Some language)

Rating: ♥♥♥♥½*

*♥♥♥♥½ = I loved it! Would re-read.

BONUS REVIEW: Botched Butterscotch by Amanda Flower

[I received an electronic review copy of this novella from Netgalley and Kensington in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.]

Summary


Bailey is looking forward to spending time with her parents, especially considering it’s Mother’s Day weekend. Aiden’s mom has invited Bailey and her parents to a Mother’s Day brunch. And the ladies have tickets for a women’s tea that weekend as well.

The tea is a fundraiser for Abigail’s Farm, a program for women in recovery who have finished rehab. Going into it, Bailey assumes the riskiest thing about the tea is having Aiden’s match-making mother spend time with Bailey’s mom. But that’s before thousands of dollars are stolen in the middle of the fundraiser.

Review


This is the second novella in the Amish Candy Shop Mystery series by Amanda Flower. It’s considered book 4.5 in the full series. Book 5, Marshmallow Malice, will release at the end of May.

This was a fast read. Readers should note this is a novella, not a full length novel. There’s no murder, and the story is pretty straightforward. Series regulars like Juliet, Aiden’s mom; her pig, Jethro; and community leader Margot make appearances. The ladies at Abigail’s Farm and their neighbors are new characters for this story.

As this is a novella, there’s not the same pacing and suspense as you would find in a full book. I missed those elements. I like the twists and turns in a full length cozy. Fans of the series will want to check this out so you have all of the adventures for your favorite characters. There’s a new pig in this story that was a hoot! If you are more interested in  a regular mystery with Bailey and Aiden and the rest of the folks in Harvest, you don’t have to wait long.

Rating: ♥♥♥½