Tag: sexism

REVIEW: Nubia: Real One by L. L McKinney

REVIEW: Nubia: Real One by L. L McKinney

Posted on by Jaymie

[I received a free electronic review copy of this book from Netgalley and DC Entertainment in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.]

Summary

You might think a second person with the powers of Wonder Woman would be welcome. But when she has brown skin like Nubia, it’s… complicated. For example, Nubia stops an armed robbery, but the victim assumes she is one of the culprits. She’s even cuffed and questioned by the police.

Nubia’s moms want her to lay low and stay out of the limelight. When her powers were discovered before, they always had to move to a new community. Nubia doesn’t want to leave her friends and a place where she is starting to feel she belongs. So she promises to keep her head down and stay out of things. But when trouble comes close to the people Nubia loves, she’ll have to decide what she is willing to risk to keep them safe.

Review

I was unfamiliar with the story of Nubia from DC comics history. This story is an amended take on the version where Nubia is Wonder Woman’s twin sister. (Yes, there’s an explanation here for the age difference.)

The Wonder Woman pieces of this are small. The larger focus is on Nubia and her peer group (friends, potential love interest), which I liked. Nubia’s friends are her world (in a good way), and they are the ones she wants to defend using her powers.

The conflict with Nubia’s moms is to be expected. They are torn between protecting her and giving her space to become the adult she is going to be. And there are also more stereotypical parent/teen conflicts they are working through as well.

My favorite parts were the places where Nubia’s journey intersects with contemporary issues – racism, sexism, sexual assault, police brutality, gun violence, etc. These very present, very real issues are placed up against Nubia’s supernatural gifts in a way I really enjoyed. (The publisher has included a content warning on the copyright page as well as reader resources in the back matter.)

Superhero fans, especially those looking for racially diverse and relevant characters and stories, should not miss this one! (Language, LGBTQ+, TW: racism, sexism, sexual assault, gun violence, school shooter)

Rating: ♥♥♥♥*

*♥♥♥♥ = Great! Might re-read.

REVIEW: Dress Coded by Carrie Firestone

REVIEW: Dress Coded by Carrie Firestone

Posted on by Jaymie

Summary

It is a truth universally acknowledged that the middle school years are some of the toughest years of childhood. Hormones, friend drama, and family issues converge with academic stress and bullies and extreme self-consciousness. For the girls at Fisher Middle School, one of the added stressors is the dress code.

A few members of the school administration take the dress code very seriously. In fact, recently, one of Molly’s friends was humiliated by the dress coding practices at the school. And, since the principal had used the dress code as the criteria for a year-end camping trip for the 8th graders, he cancelled the trip and blamed the girl, which made many of the other kids turn on her without the full story.

Molly has plenty of her own middle school drama to deal with. Her brother’s vaping has gotten so out of control that her mom quit her job so she could supervise him more closely. This means money is super tight for things like a camping trip or a graduation dress that meets the dress code. But Molly refuses to let her friend take the fall for the camping trip – or let anyone else be humiliated by the dress code policies at school. So Molly starts a podcast. And soon everyone is talking about the dress code.

Review

I was simultaneously horrified and delighted by this dress code story. The stories told in Molly’s podcast were so upsetting! But I was cheering the students on the whole time as they were brave and shared their stories. I loved that Molly refused to back down because she was going to graduate and move onto high school where no one enforced the dress code. She could not abandon her 7th grade friends or the next classes moving up. Her passion was inspiring.

The other threads here – vaping, family strife, friend drama, crushes, etc. – filled in around the dress code story. It was realistic in that the dress code obviously would not be the only thing going on in Molly’s life. I enjoyed the dress code story so much, though, that these other things – especially the vaping – felt at times like distractions. But the main thread got to be the main focus in the end. And all the pieces together helped Molly find and use her voice, both at school and at home. And I love a good story about a character finding her voice!

This would be a great story for young activists as well as for talking about dress codes, body shaming, sexism, puberty, and the rest. Young podcasters might also enjoy reading about how Molly uses her podcast to elevate the voices of the voiceless. Don’t miss this one! (LGBTQ+ and disability representation in the larger cast, TW: Bullying)

Rating: ♥♥♥♥*

*♥♥♥♥=Great! Might re-read.

REVIEW: Cinderella Is Dead by Kalynn Bayron

REVIEW: Cinderella Is Dead by Kalynn Bayron

Posted on by Jaymie

[I received an electronic review copy of this book from Netgalley and Bloomsbury YA in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.]

Summary

Two hundred years after Cinderella died, the country of Mersailles has become an oppressive place for women. They may honor the story of Cinderella with repeated readings and magical thinking and an annual ball, but the magic is all a lie.

The king reigns with an iron fist. Men are the heads of households, and whatever they do is “right” and acceptable. Anyone who doesn’t fall in line is either executed or they disappear. Girls who attend the annual ball three times without being chosen by a suitor tend to disappear, too.

Sophia doesn’t want a suitor. She wants her best friend Erin. But same-sex relationships aren’t allowed. Both girls are required by law to attend the ball and go with whatever suitor chooses them, no matter what. But when everything turns ugly that night, Sophia runs off.

She meets Constance who shares the true story of Cinderella and her family. They had challenged the king of their day – and paid the price for it. Their example, though, is just the inspiration Sophia was looking for. Maybe there’s something she can do to change life for her people who have suffered so much.

Review

This was an interesting twist on the story of Cinderella with a strong “smash the patriarchy” vibe. I was completely on board with the girls destroying the misogynistic world they suffered through, but I wasn’t 100% sold on how the fairy tale tied into the way things were. I want my fantasy stories to have well-developed world building, so I wanted more here.  But I did enjoy the twists and the way the magic system played out in the big picture, though.

The characters are interesting. I liked Constance’s connection to Cinderella and the ways her story enhanced the typical Cinderella tale. I also liked Sophia’s strength and determination throughout the story.

The romance didn’t click for me. Sophia’s immediate draw to Constance and some of their flirtations and long looks and such felt a little forced, especially when Sophia was supposedly so devoted to Erin at the start. I did appreciate Sophia’s integrity in at least trying to talk with Erin before giving into her feelings for Constance.

Fans of fairy tale retellings, fantasy stories, and fans looking for F/F romance in young adult novels should check this one out. (Language, LGBTQ+: F/F relationships, reference to M/M relationship)

Rating: ♥♥♥½