REVIEW: Star Trek: Discovering the TV Series by Tom Salinsky

[I received a free electronic review copy of this book from Netgalley and White Owl in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.]

Summary and Review


The author does a deep dive into Star Trek, watching the original series (TOS), the animated series (TAS), The Next Generation (TNG), Deep Space Nine (DS9),  Voyager (VOY), and Enterprise (ENT) in release order, one episode per day for almost two years. Initially his experience was blogged online, but now readers can be part of the journey in book form. This book only focuses on TOS, TAS, and TNG. Presumably a sequel will cover the rest.

The book covers some of the history of the franchise from Roddenberry’s early attempts to get the show produced to the return of Star Trek to television in the 80s with TNG – in addition to the episode reviews. I thoroughly enjoyed reading the episode entries. The “voice” of each one is fun and engaging. The author covers a lot of ground in just a couple paragraphs per episode.

One of the most fascinating pieces is watching the worldbuilding develop on the fly. The author points out things that show up for the first time or things that reflect decisions made later to define how the world of Star Trek will work. It was a cool addition to the episode reviews. I think fans will enjoy this – it would be great to work through this while doing your own episode review.

Rating: ♥♥♥♥*

*♥♥♥♥ – Great! Might re-read

REVIEW: What Is the Story of Captain Picard? by David Stabler

Summary


The Who HQ line of nonfiction books for kids adds the story of Jean Luc Picard to their line which also includes What Is the Story of Captain Kirk? This book includes some basic Trek history – from the timeline for TOS (The Original Series) to side bars about Rodenberry, Trek captains, and Picard’s hobbies – as well as background on the actor who plays Captain Picard, Sir Patrick Stewart. Then Picard’s story is told in highlights from key Next Generation (TNG) episodes.

Review


This is really well done! The author does a great job of synthesizing 7 seasons worth of TNG episodes to build a cohesive biography for Picard. A biography for a fictional character! Something not easy to pull off.

There’s no info dump here – nothing bogs the reader down. Tidbits of info are offered (with some spoilers) while the author moves quickly through highlights of Picard’s journey. (Although I did take issue with one instance where the author’s summary of the captain’s motives in a situation didn’t match the episode in my opinion). The book is current through initial planning and discussions of Picard season two.

I’m impressed by how deftly the author moves between reality – box office numbers, series actors, the larger Trek universe – and fiction with the life of Picard and to a lesser extent that of some of his friends. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this and highly recommend it for Star Trek fans and newbies alike.

Rating: ♥♥♥♥♥*

*♥♥♥♥♥ = Outstanding!

REVIEW: What Is the Story of Captain Kirk? by M. D. Payne

Summary and Review


This book tells the dual story of the creation of Star Trek, including the Original Series (TOS) show and movies, as well as telling the life story of main character, James T. Kirk.

This is a fun race through the highlights of a franchise with five decades of history. The book includes references to

  • the first pilot with Captain Pike
  • the movie plots of the 6 movies starring the original cast
  • descriptions of those main characters
  • a mention of the Animated Series
  • the series which followed TOS
  • the Kelvin timeline
  • some of the alien species.

As a Trek fan, this was a fun glimpse at a 50+ year phenomena. The focus stays on Kirk, so the famous Trek lore about Lucille Ball and MLK Jr. doesn’t get a mention.

There should be spoiler alerts throughout the book as the movie summaries especially are pretty revealing at times. I also felt like the publisher missed a HUGE opportunity by not including episode titles, even in footnotes or end notes, for any readers who wanted to dig deeper on something the book referenced.

Overall, this is a fun, high level look at James Kirk and the original Trek series.

Rating: ♥♥♥♥*

*♥♥♥♥ = Great! Might re-read

REVIEW: Star Trek: The Wisdom of Picard edited by Chip Carter

[I received an electronic review copy of this book from Netgalley and Adams Media in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.]

Summary and Review


This gift book/reference book includes quotes from one of Star Trek’s most well-known and well-loved captains, Jean-Luc Picard, both from The Next Generation TV series and movies as well as from the new Picard series. There are also photos of the character throughout the book.

The quotes are separated into five sections – philosophy and humanity, history and science, literature and the arts, exploration and adventure, and finally politics, leadership and diplomacy.

In my review copy, all of the quotes included the name of the episode where they came from. Only some of them included the name of the show and the season number as well. I assume that the printed versions include this information for every quote. There is no context given for the quote, other than the episode name, but sometimes the quote is given as part of the conversation it was part of.

I think this will be a fun resource for Star Trek and Picard fans. Some readers are going to recognize the quotes immediately. Others will recognize the episode titles and be able to fill in the context on their own. Still others will use the episode citations to go back and revisit the moments for a refresher.

I was sad that there was no indexing or cross referencing for the quotes. I would have liked a way to see which quotes came from which seasons or maybe which ones were said to or about a specific character or alien race. As it is, this is a fun stroll down memory lane for Star Trek fans. I’m not sure newcomers will get as much out of this except maybe as a prompt to watch a specific episode to find out more about a particular quote. But with only a few words or a few lines, I’m not sure it would be enough to draw novices in.

Rating: ♥♥♥½*

*♥♥♥½=Good+

SATURDAY SMORGASBORD: My 2019 Favorites

I read a lot of books every year.  I like to keep track of what I read every year and see how it stacks up to years before. Here are some of my reading statistics for 2019.

2019 Stats


Through the course of 2019 I read 400 books.  There were 75 more that I started but did not finish. My stated goal for the year was 300, but I was hoping to get to 365 – and I did! I’m a little behind last year’s record-setting pace (418 books read), but I am okay with where I landed. I’m pretty proud of all the reading I did this year, and even more proud of walking away from books that weren’t working for me.

Of those 400, the break down for target audience is

  • 43% adult (173 books)
  • 18% teen/young adult (70 books)
  • 19% middle grade (76 books)
  •  13% picture books (51 books)
  •   7% transitional chapter books and early readers (30 books)

And of those, 23 were graphic novels for various ages.

The main genre breakdown is

  • 31% Fantasy
  • 19% Realistic/Contemporary
  • 15% Romance
  • 13% Mystery
  • 10% Science Fiction
  • 4% Nonfiction (27 books – my goal was at least one per month)

This year most of the books I read were from the library (114 or 29%). I read 101 books from my To Be Read shelves (which are overflowing), including brand new books, as well as 106  advanced reader copies from publishers. I also re-read 39 favorites this year. Next year I want to prioritize my truly “TBR” books that have been on my shelves for awhile.

In 2019, I had a goal of reading 1-2 nonfiction books each month and I did. I also added a spreadsheet to my tracking process to see if I can better track authors and characters of color and other factors and I loved it. You can find the 2020 version of the Book Riot spreadsheet (which is customizable!) here.

In 2020, I plan to be intentional with nonfiction reading once again and make a concerted effort to get through more books on my TBR shelves. I am also participating in one book challenge.

2019 Favorites!!


At the end of the year, I love to pull the titles of all of my favorites and then compare them to come up with my favorites for the year. I might not remember every detail about them, but I remember how I felt about them. These are the books I recommend time and time again, the ones I re-read and long to re-read.

You can see my list of favorites from 2016 here and 2017 here. The list from 2018 is here.

When I went back through my list of the 400 books I read in 2019, I pulled the best of each month (something I track) for a total of 71 books in my top tier.  This year, because of some re-reads that made it into the list and the way the numbers fell, it was better to go with 12 than 10. So here they are – my 2019 favorites:

12. A Duke by Default – Book 2 in the Reluctant Royals series. You can read my summary of the series here. This book was my favorite of the series, and a favorite from 2019, because of the characters, especially Portia. I loved reading about her efforts to improve herself and work on her personality quirks.

 

 

11. Star Trek Discovery: The Way to the Stars – Sylvia Tilly is my favorite character on Star Trek Discovery, and this book just reinforced that love. This reads a bit like a YA coming-of-age-story to me, which is a feature, not a bug. I adored reading this, and I’m looking forward to reading it again in 2020. (The latest Discovery novel, Dead Endless, focuses on other characters, but that author does a terrific job with Tilly, too.)

 

 

10. Well Met –  A woman coming home to help her sister after an accident is roped into participating in the local Renaissance Faire. Her lighthearted take on the faire puts her in conflict with the man responsible for the volunteers who bears the weight of his family’s legacy. This was a delight from the first page! I already have book 2 on my wish list. This is one I will read again. (♥♥♥♥♥)

 

 

9. Deadly Little Scandals – Book 2 after the delightful Little White Lies. While I rated this a 4.5 and most of the books on this list were 5s, the intricate, twisty plotting of this was something I couldn’t forget. When I compared this to other books on the list, that masterful level of plotting helped this rise above other titles.

 

 

8. The Storm – This is book 6 in the Sons of Destiny series, a romance/fantasy series I re-read usually once every year. It’s unusual for a re-read to make my top favorites of the year, but there are two on the list this year. I’ve written about this book before because it focuses on my favorite of the 8 brothers in the series. I especially enjoyed my re-read this year. I felt like I picked up on nuances with the character that I hadn’t considered before, which is why this rose to the top of the stack when compared to some of the other books I read this year. The emotional depths of this particular book get me every time. (♥♥♥♥♥)

 

7. Prince in Disguise – The second re-read that made my top 12 this year is this delightful YA romance by Stephanie Kate Strohm. The first time I read it, I rated it a 5+++, which is my way of saying a book is among the best of the best. (You can see some other five-plus reviews here.)  In my re-reading, that rating held fast, which doesn’t always happen. I find this book to be a perfect “comfort read” when I need a book I know I am going to adore.

 

 

6. Spiritual Rhythms for the Enneagram – This is the only nonfiction book to make my favorites list this year. I didn’t read a ton of nonfiction in 2019, and what I did read, while mostly enjoyable, didn’t stick with me enough to rise to the top of the list. But I got so much out of this book, and I think about the things I learned when I read it. I have it in a stack of resources I want to read through again in order to glean some more of its wisdom. You can read about this book, and the other Enneagram books I read in 2019, here.

 

 

5. The Bookish Life of Nina Hill – 2019 was the year of romance and romantic comedies for me. And this was one of my favorites! In fact it’s another book on the list that received a 5+ rating. One of my favorite features of this book, in addition to the terrific story, is the smart, snappy writing. It begs to be read aloud. You can read my full review here.

 

 

4. The Boy Next Story – Book 2 in the Bookish Boyfriends series after A Date with Darcy. I adored the first book so much, I was afraid book 2 couldn’t possibly live up to my expectations, but it actually exceeded them. I knew back in April when I first read this that this book would end up on my 2019 favorites list.  This was another 5+ book for me and I can’t wait to see what comes next in this terrific YA series.  You can read my full review here.

 

 

3. 10 Blind Dates – This YA romance was hysterical, and I absolutely adored it.  The premise is fantastic and clever, and the execution was even better. This was the book I was telling everyone about this fall. Here’s my full review.

 

 

 

2. The Blacksmith Queen – A prophecy about a rising queen to replace the recently dead king angers his sons who want no part of anything that would force them to give up the throne. When it looks like the new queen will be her younger sister, a blacksmith gathers supporters to help her defend her family.

There was a tie for first place in my tally at the end of 2019. When I list the top book, I’ll tell you how it edged out this one for first place, but both are fantastic. This is a quirky book, and I cackled my way through it from the first page to the last. When I see this in the book store, it’s often shelved in romance, but I think it makes more sense in fantasy as that is the bigger plot line, at least in my opinion. It’s more violent (and gruesome) than I usually find in romance stories, and at times it was even more than I expected from a fantasy story. But I was hooked by the premise and drawn in by the humor and the characters. I can’t wait for book 2.

 

1. Polaris Rising – I read this awesome sci-fi/romance twice in 2019, and BOTH times it ended up on my best-of-the-month lists, which is why I gave this the top spot for 2019 after the tie with The Blacksmith Queen. I loved the characters in this and the world building. You can read my review here. Book 2, Aurora Blazing, was also great. And book 3, Chaos Reigning, can’t get into my hands soon enough!

 

 

 

Honorable Mention


None of the middle grade, mystery or picture books that I enjoyed this year made it to the top 12. But here are the top two in each category.

Middle Grade: Broken Strings AND Finding Orion

Picture Books: Madeline Finn and the Shelter Dog AND Pluto Gets the Call (follow the link here for a description)

Mysteries: Murder Once Removed AND Restaurant Weeks Are Murder (follow the link here for a description)

 

What were YOUR favorite books in 2019?

REVIEW: The Way to the Stars (Star Trek Discovery) by Una McCormack

Summary


On the eve of her start in the Command Training Program, Tilly shares her personal story with her Discovery roommate Michael Burnham.

When Sylvia Tilly was 16, she lived with her maternal grandmother in Paris and went to school every day in New York. Her parents were divorced. Her dad was on a starship, The Dorothy Garrod, and her mom was a bigwig with the Federation Security Council. Frankly, her mom was a force to be reckoned with. She often left Sylvia feeling small and trapped – like she felt when her mom announced she was sending her to a boarding school on Talaris IV. Sylvia’s mom was determined to give her daughter every opportunity to develop the skills she would need to join the diplomatic corps. She didn’t see Sylvia’s love of math and science as anything to cultivate when there were languages to learn and political scenarios to understand.

The ups and downs of boarding school life set Sylvia/”Tilly” on a path she never could have imagined when she first stepped foot onto Talaris IV.

Review


This book’s intended audience is adults, but Tilly’s story is so solidly in the YA range, too, that I wanted to review it as a YA coming-of-age tale.

Tilly is my favorite character on the show Star Trek Discovery. So when I saw she was getting a book, it immediately went on my “must read” list. And now that I’ve read it, it’s on my “must buy list.” This was outstanding! A perfect-fit book for me.

The Star Trek pieces were comfortable and familiar, as was the general story of a teen seeking her identity while under the thumb of a controlling parent. And I loved all those pieces. But Tilly really made this story for me. She’s wicked smart and funny. She’s also endearing and awkward. I wanted to rescue her from her mother’s controlling ways. But it was so much more satisfying to watch her rescue herself. Her journey wasn’t flawless, but it was delightful! I am a sucker for a book with a kid or a teen who finds his/her place/gift/identity and then thrives in it. And this was that sort of story.

The Star Trek Discovery connections are minimal, mostly just the prologue and epilogue which anchor the character to the TV series. But if you know that Michael Burnham is a woman, and she’s Tilly’s roommate on the ship – older, with more life and Star Fleet experience, maybe a reluctant mentor – you probably have everything you need to know to enjoy the book.

I highly recommend this book. In fact, after typing up this review, I want to go read it again! (Some language, minor consumption of alcohol)

Rating: ♥♥♥♥♥

REVIEW: Randoms by David Liss

Summary


Zeke Reynolds is one of four Earth kids chosen to spend a year in space learning about the Confederation of United Planets. If the kids perform well, Earth will be invited to join the Confederation. The three other kids were chosen because of their skills – academic, martial arts, chess/strategy. Zeke was chosen by chance. He’s the “random.”

Historically, teams have chosen to ostracize the Random and try to win without him or her. Zeke tries not to care – he wants Earth to join the Confederation so his mom will get a cure for her ALS. He hangs out with the other Randoms and hopes to help his team as well as his new friends as he can.

But Zeke keeps running into obstacles. The Earth chaperone keeps trying to throw him under the bus and get him kicked out of the competition – or worse. Zeke saves a ship under attack and somehow becomes the villain in the story. One of the other delegates is out to get Zeke. And plenty of folks are keeping secrets. Zeke is going to have to prove himself in a lot of ways if he wants to save his mom.

Review


This is an excellent science fiction story with tons of awesome sci-fi references and lots of laughs. I read this on the recommendation of my teen, and he nailed this recommendation. This book was right up my alley!

The characters in the story are great. Zeke is funny, smart and sarcastic. His pop culture references – especially for Star Trek and Star Wars – are endearing (at least to this Star Trek/Star Wars fan!). The other characters – human and alien – are well defined with interesting quirks, alliances and agendas.

The story is compelling. I cared about Zeke’s success first because of his mom and then because I liked him. I wanted him to overcome the obstacles placed in his path. As the “mystery” developed, I kept flipping pages to see how Zeke and his friends were going to survive, much less if they would succeed in earning membership in the Confederation.

The story ended with something of a cliffhanger. Several loose ends were left dangling. I will obviously have to sneak the sequel, Rebels, from my teen so I can find out what happens next. Book 3, Renegades, releases this fall.

Rating: ♥♥♥♥½

REVIEW: Star Trek: 50 Artists, 50 Years by Titan Books

Summary


Star Trek Art!! Fifty artists created a piece that reflected something from Star Trek. This book is part of the celebration of the 50th anniversary of the first episode airing on television. Each page includes a 10.5×14.5 inch image of the artwork. There is also an interview with the artist. Interview questions include the artist’s connection to Star Trek and their inspiration and process for creating their piece

Star Trek Art

Review


This book is eye candy for Star Trek lovers! I wouldn’t call myself an art lover in general. I know what I like but I can’t always say why I like it. But I am a Star Trek lover, and I am fascinated by this book. The pieces are mostly from The Original Series (TOS) or The Next Generation (TNG). There are some glimpses of the artist’s other ideas besides the piece they ultimately submitted. After the art itself, my favorite parts are the artists’ stories about their connection to Star Trek. Some are reluctant fans, some watched it because a family member did, and some are huge fans in their own rights.

Rating: ♥♥♥♥♥

If you aren’t sure about purchasing the whole book, you can get a calendar (roughly the same size as the book) with 12 of the pieces included. They are 11×14 and could easily be framed. Star Trek Poster Calendar for 2017.